So I fell from Grace is finally here!
It's been many, many months in the making, with hundreds of hours of testing to ensure there are no bugs for launch, and of course I overlooked a new menu element and how it might interact with other menus.
There was a minor bug in the launch release where if you chose to start the game over, and at the warning screen for starting a new game when a save is already detected, the options menu would steal focus and stay there.
I've just pushed out an updated that addresses this issue.