So while working on the chapter with Emily, I went to review the image where her eyes glow. Then I notice that the shadows look..weird.
To summarize my postwork process: I make "masks" for skin, hair, and clothes so I can make adjustments. I try to make sure I save the right PSD file with the masks so if I need to redo the images, it looks the same. Well..key word is try. For reason, I didn't save that file right and it was a bit dark so I didn't see the odd shapes until now. This fixes that.